You’re Doing it Wrong.

In our ex-city, there is a shop which sells Indian food. I can’t even remember the name of it, because I know where it is, so why would I need to know the name of the shop?* The point of this is that the shop sold frozen parathas and chapatis, and they were very tasty. They also sold homemade samosas on Fridays and Saturdays, and, even though it was a drive, sometimes I would deviate from whatever errands I was running, to get a couple for the Handsome Sidekick and myself to have for dinner.

Mmm, samosas.

But even though the samosas were amazing, it’s the breads we miss. We eat a fair bit of Indian food, so I’ve started experimenting again with making my own Indian bread. I decided to start with naan, since I’ve made it before and it seemed more forgiving than chapatis (it’s thicker, and less likely to stick). Into the depths of the internet I dived, to find a good naan recipe.

I checked out about eight. Most of them were similar. They varied in the number of servings, the resting time, whether they were to be baked in an oven or fried on a hotplate, whether they contained yeast or eggs or salt. So I read through all these recipes, and then took note of the things they had in common, and what I wanted to work with, and created a recipe from that.

As I was kneading out the dough, I started thinking about recipes and how I’m almost compelled to change them, even the first time I make the food. It’s as if I want to rebel at being told how to make something, even though the person who wrote the recipe doubtless had reasons for including or leaving out certain ingredients. Most of the time, though, the recipe can handle some tweaking. Occasionally, such tweaking results in disaster, but not often. There are just a lot ways to get similar results. Plus, I’m cooking for my tastes, and those of my family. I know them, the person writing the recipe did not (and said person is obviously cooking for his/her own tastes, as well).

This seems relevant in the greater scheme of things, because I seem to be coming across the ‘you’re doing it wrong’ sentiment a lot recently. Second Offspring seems to have this particular whinge on replay, when the rules she’s so carefully decided upon don’t seem to mesh with what her siblings want to do. For her, ‘you’re doing it wrong’ basically translates to: ‘you’re doing it a different way to the way I had imagined in my head, which I had decided in advance was ‘right’, and therefore your non-compliance to my rules, which I’ve not necessarily communicated with you, makes me utterly livid’.

At her age, ‘black and white’ is standard point of view. I’m sure that will change in a few years. Until then, she has to bump into opposition regularly, and learn to make compromises. It’s a gradual move towards an emotionally mature person, and one day, I imagine (or hope!) she’ll get there.

She’s not the only one, however. I seem to hear the ‘you’re doing it wrong’ like a mantra, from so many different directions, and in light of Second Offspring’s outbursts at her siblings, it made me wonder why people are so adamant that their view is the right one, and those of others is so wrong? You’re doing your diet wrong (or you’re doing the wrong diet); you’re doing your religion wrong (or you’re following the wrong religion); you’re making that recipe wrong (or you’re using the wrong recipe, and making the wrong food); you’re using ‘wrong’ wrong (when it should be ‘wrongly’)!

Putting aside that there are many ways to get the same result, what is it about knowing we’re ‘right’ which is so satisfying, and why do we need others to accept this, in order to feel justified? Surely, if we have enough confidence in what we believe, it shouldn’t matter what others think?  I’m not saying healthy discourse should be discouraged.  I’ve enjoyed many a discussion on various topics, where I’ve held a different belief to colleagues or friends, and we’ve still been able to see each other’s points of view, probably because nobody has been insistent on his or her point of view being the only valid one.

Having one’s own ideas challenged is not only a valuable way of reassessing the validity of these ideas, it’s also a method by which to convince people that this is a way fit to emulate. Just yelling the loudest in the hopes it will drown out all others seems like a very five year old approach, which, if Second Offspring’s siblings’ reaction is anything to go by, is fairly ineffective.

It’s true that there are many ways to do something wrong. But telling someone that before they even begin isn’t going to necessarily prevent them from making mistakes. Sometimes, they just need to make mistakes. And then, when they get around to doing it right, it still might not be the way we’d imagined. It’s just important to accept that doing it in some other way does not necessarily equate to ‘wrong’. It means different, and while that might be confronting, it’s probably good for us. Even doing it wrong can sometimes lead to some amazing discoveries, and it can lead to some disastrous meals. Either way, it’s far more interesting than just listening to a one-way-only dictate, and what’s more, it provides opportunity to learn, and discover, and create. Perhaps what’s needed is less of the accusatory ‘you’re doing it wrong’, and more of a congratulatory, ‘you’re doing it!’

027It worked!  Naan with chickpea and potato curry.  Yum!

*I tend to do this with destinations and directions, a lot. It gets difficult if I have to tell people how to get places. Apparently not everyone navigates via landmarks.

13 thoughts on “You’re Doing it Wrong.

  1. Pingback: You’re Doing it Wrong. | ugiridharaprasad

  2. My Dad was a master builder. Hubby had to make a step for our back door, and could imagine Dad was watching him from Above. The end result was nicknamed Little Bedrock (after The Flintstones) and did the deed, but didn’t look ‘professional’. He swore he heard Dad say ‘I wouldn’t have done it that way myself, but it works!’ Dad never knocked anyone for trying.

  3. I get a lot of this…I guess we all do. Often from people who hardly know me. A colleague at work getting quite annoyed because I’m home-schooling my kids; my boss in the academic department where I work, dismissing my plans for a future outside of academia. It seems to me that people feel threatened when you do something in a different way – whether that’s making naan or choosing an alternative path through life. I want to say ‘This is not about you’. My rejection of formal education or of a traditional career path does not (should not) reflect on your choices in life. I accept the path you are walking; please have the courtesy to respect my path. The naan recipe in our family is a right mash-up – and it tastes damn good!!

    • Oh, I’m sure you get all sorts of hassle for homeschooling, especially. It really is not about them, what you do. But their comments ARE all about them. I remember saying to a friend that I wanted to do teaching, and because I was doing my Masters at that point, he said, ‘can’t you do something better?’ Grrr.

  4. So true. Having lots of the same thoughts myself lately as I watch my son and his friends navigate adulthood and parenting. I must respect their choices and have realized that comments and suggestions which I feel might save them some pain, might actually keep them from learning the lesson and me from learning something new!

  5. First of all: it looks like you’re doing that naan right! 🙂

    Secondly: I’m struggling with this very issue in a self-reflective way as I go through my Benedictine Canon novitiate. Benedict doesn’t mince words: he lays out what a good monk is supposed to do, and he lists consequences for those who fail. Today’s blurb from the Rule says that monks should not be too hasty (or ready) to laugh. I find this a hard teaching. How do I resist this without being wrong, according to the Rule? How do I hear truth in what Benedict says?

    Seeking what is true in what punches us (so to speak) in the gut just isn’t easy, is it?

    • It was pretty fine😀

      Yeah, that is difficult. Because I can imagine that there is quite a divide between the life Benedict had, and the life you lead. Not being too ready to laugh… it kind of goes against how I want to live! I want to laugh more, not less! Perhaps he is trying to say that there needs to be more reflection, more forethought, instead of laughter? A more measured response, rather than a gut reaction? I really don’t know. I hope there is a way to interpret this without having to give up on spontaneous laughter!

      I don’t think seeking truth is ever easy. Especially if you find it!

  6. Oh, how I wish I could have your naan recipe. We have one Indian restaurant here in Cuenca, and the food was abysmal. Plus, it’s impossible to buy naan here, so I figured I’d start baking my own.

    By the way, we are having our first taste of parenting, as my nephew (20-years-old) has come to live with us for 6 months.

    Hugs from Ecuador,
    Kathy

    • Would you like it? I’m happy to share🙂 We were sure we would suffer, moving from an area where there were so many different kinds of food (we lived in a very multicultural area in our other city) to a much smaller place, but in fact, there are three Indian restaurants here, and so far, the food is pretty good. I still miss the one we used to go to, but I can live with what we’ve got!

      What fun to have your nephew live with you for six months! I’m sure he will love exploring Ecuador with his cool aunts🙂 At least you won’t have to change any nappies, which is just as well, considering what your other ‘children’ have been up to!

      Best,
      Bec

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s