Saying Nice Things, or Saying Nothing At All.

I wasn’t going to write about Cory Bernadi today.  I had something else on which I was working, and there were other reasons, as well.  I haven’t read his book, so I’m basing my thoughts on this morning’s article, plus others.  I also figured that there is going to be a chorus of indignant voices raised in response to this article, so why add mine to the mix?

Well, that’s never stopped me before!  And the article this morning really ticked me off. If I write about it, I’ll get it out of my system, and then perhaps I can focus on other topics, which I feel are more worthy of my time.

I know that the ABC has likely cherry-picked quotes to ensure the article is read and shared by the greatest number of people.  On the other hand, the quotes are certainly not out of character for this politician.  Formerly the parliamentary secretary to the Prime Minister, Tony Abbott, he resigned and headed to the back bench after claiming that allowing same sex marriages could encourage bestiality.

Now he has written a book in which he has managed to offend a whole new group of people.  Or perhaps that should be ‘groups’.  Or perhaps that should be ‘huge great swathes of the population’.

Bernadi argues that the abortions in Australia are a ‘death industry’, and that ‘traditional families’ are superior to other kinds, such as stepfamilies (and basically any other in which the parent/s are not married, or heterosexual, or whose children are not conceived ‘naturally’, or are not biologically theirs).  He also claims that one of the threats against Christianity and traditional values is the ‘green agenda’,  placing the value of animal and plant life over that of humans.

I was trying to identify what exactly it was that I found so annoying about Bernadi’s arguments, or at least those quoted by the ABC website. I mean, he’s gone to so much trouble to list his issues with what has gone wrong with our country, it seems a shame to choose just one to refute, doesn’t it? But in fact, all his arguments boil down to one assumption.

Bernadi is like every other right wing idealist, in that he seems to believe that all the problems of our modern society would go away if only we were to return to some golden era, where men were men and women were women and they married (and never divorced) and had children and all was right with the world. A time when there were none of those pesky homosexuals, when abortions didn’t exist, when everyone went to church, when humans were confident of their rightful place in nature (at the top of the food chain, and not part of it).

Wouldn’t it be nice to go back to that time? Wouldn’t it just make things so much simpler? Oh, if only! And we could be rid of this confusing mess in which we find ourselves, which is destroying us from within!

But there was never such a time. There might have been, for some members of society, but only because they chose to ignore that there have always been unhappy marriages, or infertility, or unwanted pregnancies, or unhappy people unable to have the relationships they really wanted. The problems with our society are not because of some failure to attend church, and not because people are divorcing–or not marrying–or having children via IVF. The problems we face are because we’re humans, and we bicker with each other, and are greedy, and take a long time to learn from our mistakes. But we do evolve. Ever so slowly, but it happens. And in our evolution, we begin to ask questions about equality, and our place in the world, and how we treat others, and how we want our future to look.

Cory Bernadi wants to court a small part of the population and argue that their worldview is under attack, when all that is really happening is that this worldview is having to share the stage with others. Perhaps the saddest part of this is how he throws his religion into the mix. In a country like Australia, where church-going is hardly the Sunday past-time of choice, (whether or not they believe in a Christian god), most people are not going to be swayed when he claims that our country is suffering because we have strayed from the path of Christianity. And I can’t help feeling a little dismissive of his views, when he says that faith and Christianity are under threat by environmentalists and Islam. Under threat? Just how fragile is his faith, if it cannot withstand challenges such as other religions or a different political perspective? The last time I looked, people from different faiths and political persuasions challenge each other all the time. Sometimes–wait for it–they can even respect each other, and get along.

Other times, they fight wars.

What does Cory Bernadi want to do? Get along, or fight a war? Considering the way in which he has clashed even with members within his own party, considering he has already lost one job and is willing to jeopardise his place in his political party, I guess he is willing to fight. I think he wants to foster a strong conservative future for Australia; I believe he is fired up and ready to step up to defend his faith and his right wing values from the rest of us, who obviously have lost our way, because we simply want people to be able to live their lives and be content. Cory Bernadi is ready to stand up for that in which he believes, and do whatever it takes to battle this out.

Call it typical Australian apathy, but I’m not sure many of us can really be bothered taking him seriously enough to fight back. Lucky for us, we’re in the majority.

Now let’s see what we can do about that green agenda, and same sex marriage, shall we?


11 thoughts on “Saying Nice Things, or Saying Nothing At All.

  1. In a small way, I took heart from the linked article. It was oddly soothing to know that such views are not confined to my own country (that one between Canada and Mexico). I probably missed some nuances due to similar words meaning different things (‘Medicare’, for example), but it seemed so much like one side of our own polarized politics.

    In a bigger way, I took heart from someone taking it on in a gentler way (gentler than Bernardi, at least) and still striking it down so effectively. I appreciate anger being opposed by quieter anger. Although, since I think I agree with your views, I may your expression as more civilized than, say, Bernardi would.

    • Thank you for reading!The stupid thing about this guy, is his is not exactly part of a chorus of voices in politics. If anything, it’s a bit of a lone voice which appears to be (from the limited access I have to your country’s media and politics) more suited to US politics than to ours. That’s in fact one other reason why I didn’t really think I should write on it, because he is after the drama and the media attention and I wasn’t sure I wanted to give it to him. You know, because my blog is so renowned and of national importance, obviously it will make a huge impact, now I’ve written on it ;P

      But in the end, his arguments are so flawed. I just couldn’t let it go.

      (I know what you mean about the Medicare thing–here, it’s our national public health system, whereas I think it’s a specific programme in the US for only certain parts of the population, right?)

      • Yeah, Medicare here is generally (not exclusively) for retired folks, people who don’t commonly require abortions …

        That Liberal Party is conservative? That’s something a little mind-bending though.

      • I know, crazy, right? I was just explaining to a(nother USican) friend that one often hears people talking about Australian politics in terms of ‘small-L’ liberals and ‘big-L’ liberals. It can be confusing. Although the politics is so opposite from each other, it’s not really, I suppose. Heh.

  2. Wonderful post. I must admit, I don’t know anything about this fellow other than what you have shared. Sorry to say, I’m really ignorant about Australian politics–really ignorant. Obviously, I wouldn’t agree with you more. I’m just glad that since Sara and I married in New York state a little over 8 months ago, that marriage equality is the law in twice as many states. It’s gone from 9 to 18. Gay marriage is even legal now in Utah, of all places.

    Hugs from Ecuador,

    • Thank you! Believe me, I know very little about Ecuadorian politics! I only know about US politics because it is very loud politics, if you get my gist! And of course, the Australian stuff pertains to daily life for us 😀

      I am really happy that parts of the US have been progressive in allowing marriage equality, and I hope that trend continues, as I think it will. Here, we’re still… struggling with it. Most Australians want it, and yet, with a conservative government in power right now, I don’t know if it will happen for a good while. We’ll see, I suppose. There is a politician I am quietly interested in, who might be biding his time to challenge the leadership and therefore the Prime Ministership, and he is favour of marriage equality (and against people like Bernadi), so there is hope. There’s always hope!

  3. Interesting read. I have never herad of this guy before, but I must admitt the more I read the more scary this man looks. I hope you’ll be many people taking him seriously and fight him back. I agree with you that this is a very important fight to take. I’m lucky to come from a contry with a relatively high level of equality, but there are always battles to fight and people with scary opinions that should not have their opinions stand un-opposed.

    • Thank you 🙂 He’s already taken a bit of a hiding in the press, thank goodness! I definitely agree that there is an element of danger here, because he’s doing what people of his ilk do: making a claim we can generally agree with (marriage break-ups can be difficult for children) and running with it to arrive at ridiculous conclusions (children from families where the marriages have broken down are more likely to be criminals or promiscuous). I think right now, he’s looking for publicity and wants to sell his book. I also think that he’s being so ridiculous that enough of the population is going to roll their eyes and ignore him. I doubt he’s going to get any support from his own party, and our system of government generally works against independents.

      Either way, the more people who just realise that this guy is after his fifteen minutes and that his policies AND his politics are pathetic, the better.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s